Popa Jim's Pizza - Avis

New owners of previously owned and operated pizza shop. Thought I would try them since I was a big fan of previous owners and their products. I was very pleased...

I am in Big Pine visiting my parents. They insisted on ordering from The Island Pizza Company because the previous owners (when it was called Papa Jim's) had gr...

Wish I could say the review was based on their food but the inability to call an order in has prevented me from trying their food. The message is rude, and onli...

Love the food! Best pizza on BPK. Looking forward to the new ownership changes. Oh

Horrible service. The owner yells on people for not putting mask on face IN THE CAR. Red pizza is mediocre , white pizza was good but VERY EXPENSIVE! I will not...

Pizza is excellent. Staff was pleasant and accommodating. My opinion is the new owners are doing an excellent job and deserve the communities support.

Food is great, new owners, if your gonna own a pizza joint u gotta put in the hours not set the hours to only equsl 40hrs a week???? It's like why even bother j...

Probably the best pizza I’ve had since living in the Florida keys. It’s seriously delicious and the owner and staff are very kind and friendly. Definitely recom...

Just picked up pizza with bacon and sausage, which the owner delivered right to our car. He was very nice and personable so I don't understand why others gave s...

By far the best pizza I have found in the Florida Keys. This shop would be competitive even in the New York, New Jersey area.