Underhill Cafe &grill - Brooklyn

This restaurant is a charming neighborhood gem in Brooklyn. It's a cozy place with excellent food and drink selections, and you feel like a regular from the moment you step in, even if it’s your first visit. Despite being busy and having a small staff, they provided attentive service with laughter and smiles.

LEARN FROM MY MISTAKE: DO NOT MAKE A RESERVATION HERE. UNFORTUNATELY, THIS RESTAURANT LACKS PROFESSIONALISM. Like many others, we received a call less than an hour before our reservation confirming that our 7:30 PM booking on a Saturday night would not be honored due to their overwhelming busyness.

The restaurant was closed on Sunday morning. I was able to make a reservation on OpenTable, but I couldn't eat there.

Amazing food, service and value. Always consistent and that is key to creating and sustaining a great restaurant and experience for customers.

This is one of those amazing neighborhood gems in Brooklyn. It's a cozy spot with excellent food and drink options, making you feel right at home, even if it's your first visit. The small staff was delightful, and they took great care of us with laughter and smiles throughout our meal.