Extreme Pizza - Caldwell

I’d give them a solid 4. But sometimes when you call there’s no answer. I’m a celiac, their gluten free is great and hasn’t made me sick. I’ve ordered a few times now. But I’m not able to order online. If you can’t get through on the phone you can’t order.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free

What a gem ? in Caldwell! Great atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious food. Thanks for offering GF optionsDietary restrictions: GF available

Overall great options, polite and friendly staff, in a cozy location surrounded by many other commercial options. The dough is probably the only weak point; when served to you it's awesome, but too long in the fridge and the crust on the rim is super chewy.Buuuut, their sides are awesome, most pizza place's sides are eh.Is it the best pizza? Nah. Is it Good Pizza? Yes! Is it GREAT PIZZA? I think so, but some people might be pickier. Hence a 4 star. Also it's a little pricey sometimes, so I tend to alternate between here and one other place.

Worst service ever!!!!!! Have had several bad experiences to outweigh who much I like their food. Won't be back.

I took my husband here today, I had had this pizza a couple of times, but he hadn 't yet, and his dad owns the #1 Italian restaurant in Anchorage, so he 's a lot picky. First bite and the first thing out of his mouth, I 'm impressed! Phew! Because I already loved it. The staff misheard me when I ordered and mistakenly made us an incorrect pizza, but they were quick to resolve the issue and let us keep both pizzas, this is customer service you don 't find this day in age.Between the flavor of the pizza itself, the customer service, the cleanliness of the restaurant, and the welcoming atmosphere, I think they 've got some lifelong customers here.