Shy Simon's Pizza - Council

In my humble opinion, this is the best handmade pizza anywhere. Every time we head north and go through Council we stop at Shy Simon's.

The pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in the area and the service can’t be beat! The price is great as well!

Very rude customer service.. my order was forgotten about and brought to me cold..would never return or recommend to anyone... they have won awards by being the only pizza place In town..I'm sure the local receive better service

Shy Simon's pizza was such a delightful surprise of deliciousness.

After a visit to McCall, we were looking for an on-the-way-back-to-Boise pizza place. The usual in Donnelly showed bad recent reviews, so we went out of our way for Shy Simon 's. We were not disappointed! Fresh ingredients, prompt service, and more than enough portions on the pizza. The Pesto was delicious!