New York Slices - Highland Park

Do not order from here. We have had numerous frustrating issues, including pizza and salad left on our porch with no notification, and an order cancelled because they were out of lettuce and could not make our salad. While the pizza is solid when you can get it, the customer service is all but non-existent (e.g., interacting with the frustrating and minimally-helpful Slice app, a business phone number that just rings through to a harsh fax line busy signal). We will never order from here again and encourage you to not waste your time.

Great pizza! Friendly staff! Very urban ambiance. *mental transporta to NY* during the first bite!

Y'all really need to hire better staff or something, because wow... Lol. My boyfriend and I went here to get a couple of slices of pizza, and the cashier was clearly high. He seemed super out of it and barely warmed up our pizza. Also, while we were there, two people came in to pick up their online orders and they were both told that there was no record of their order when they clearly had their receipts. Not sure why there wasn't a manager around or something. So unprofessional. It's too bad because this place used to be really good.

Ordered a grandmas pizza and when I got home after picking it up the dough was raw and goey. Supper greasy and no crust whatsoever it’s just like a half cooked pizza. Also ordered the garlic bread. Pretty gross. Tastes artificial and absolutely no garlic flavor. Can’t recommend this place at all definetely not a quality New York pizzeria.

Pizza is fantastic. Big foldable cheesy slices. As a former New York resident, I can say that this is the real deal.