Godfathers Pizza - Kawartha Lakes

I have ordered countless pizzas in my lifetime, and I have to say that this place serves the worst pizza I have ever tasted. The toppings were scarce, the crust was undercooked, and there was an excessive amount of oil oozing from the cheese and toppings. When I brought the pizza home, it was practically swimming in oil. My advice to anyone considering eating here is to save yourself the trouble and go to the grocery store instead. Simply grab a frozen pizza from the freezer aisle - it will be a much better choice than anything you'll get from this restaurant.

We decided to give this restaurant several chances after our first visit in December 2020. The food itself is not the issue, but the problem lies in the online ordering system for pick-up, which is consistently confusing and inaccurate. Despite the fact that there is a Godfathers Pizza just 7 minutes away from our home in Fenelon, we are willing to travel to Peterborough just to avoid the poor service. Goodbye to this subpar experience!

Called to place an order for delivery and was told no they had 9 deliveries and to call back later ...didn't recognize the person who answered (male) ..the girls are great ...I would have waited for my order as I understand it when its busy that it could be awile for delivery . I've used godfathers since I moved to bobcaygeon (4 yrs)will be trying Luigi's

Greetings to all my dear friends, thank you very much for reading the messages. In fact, the food they have is very delicious and everything is suitable and fast and excellent service. I wish you happiness always and success

Hi Godfather, I'm visiting from Mississauga. my advuse please learn to make Pizza. the cheese is something....doesn't taste like cheese. your sauce has no taste, it's yuck. we threw out half the pizza. please visit the GTA and taste the pizza and tell the difference. All the best