Sift Bake Shop Mystic

On September 23, 2022, I finally got the chance to visit this restaurant after several unsuccessful attempts due to long lines. Fortunately, today I only had to wait 15 minutes before being greeted by one of the many friendly staff members. They were incredibly patient and helpful throughout our visit. It was a real challenge to choose just a few items from the menu because everything looked and smelled delicious, from drinks to food. We decided to go with coffee, tea, and some sweet treats. The only downside is that indoor seating is limited, but there is plenty of outdoor seating available. This place is definitely a must-visit if you're in the area, no matter how long the wait may be — it's absolutely worth it!

During my first visit, I was truly impressed by how modern, simple, and beautifully arranged everything was in the bakery. My good friend brought me here because she recently started working here (Hi Sarah, you’re going to do amazing!). I ordered the Chocolate Sea Salt Walnut cookie and two chocolate croissants (which take three days to prepare), along with a box of their macarons. The cookie was not only the size of my hand but also perfectly chewy and bursting with flavor in every bite. The croissants were incredibly detailed and layered to perfection. The staff was very friendly, welcoming, and patient. I’ll definitely be stopping by again whenever I'm in Mystic!

A charming little bakery in Mystic. The baked goods look absolutely delightful. It always seems to be bustling with customers. They offer a variety of both sweet and savory items, along with coffee. Definitely a great spot to visit when you're in the area!

Sift truly was amazing! It was worth all the hype we heard about it and then some honestly! The line was out the door but within 5 minutes we were ordering our food! Staff was super nice and recommended some options. We got 2 iced coffees and decided on thecinnamon roll center and avocado toast but it was so hard to decide cause everything looked so delicious!! It was SO GOOD ????Will definitely go back if we're in town. Such a good experience!

Damn!!! Evidently Adam Young, the baker/owner won some Baking award. Congratulations. But you know what, don't care, just don't stop baking dude. So much tasty goodness. The smell alone in this place will send your senses into overload of bliss. We wereup early and out the door of our AirBnB (8 AM), we asked a local walker where to get decent coffee and she recommendedSift. Evidently we hit a sweet spot arrival time on a Friday morning in August, because normally there is a line out the door.We did not experience that. The young lady that helped us was very sweet and efficient. The baked goods were super highquality. You can separate the tastes and textures as you enjoy. Party in my mouth. Highly recommend!!