Jackie Reilly's Grill - Plainedge

Always a pleasure seeing Sean. The food a service were great. The atmosphere second to none. A great place

Every time my girlfriend and I go here we have an amazing experience! Danny behind the bar is a true gentleman and excellent bartender. I work at bars in upstate NY and when we come down to visit my parents we look forward to stopping by for a drink and bite to eat. Customers are friendly and welcoming as well. This is the place to go especially late night on a week day!! Thanks Danny see you soon!!! 5 STARS

I ordered a couple of drinks and appetizers. Unfortunately, my drink tasted like watered-down Bacardi and Coke, and the food was overcooked. We ended up sending the chicken tenders back, and I only ate the potato skins because I was really hungry, but they weren’t great either. It seemed like they were understaffed, as our waitress was always busy and couldn't give each table the attention it deserved. However, the interior was nice and clean.

This is a charming, classic Irish pub that reminds me of the ones in NYC. I would give it three stars because I ordered food from their website (the wings were fantastic, by the way), but I noticed that the prices were different when I went to pick up my order. It seems they need to update their website with the correct prices. The food was a bit expensive overall; while the wings were excellent, the other items were just average. I ended up spending over $50 for three appetizers, which feels a bit steep. However, I would definitely come back just for those wings!

We were here for a birthday party. Just stayed chatted for a few minutes. Wine served was OK. Wait staff very nice accommodating.