Crabby Amy's, - Seaford

This is an outside seating only restaurant. It's located in a marina and has a nice neighborhood, casual vibe. The seafood is VERY GOOD and fresh. Check out the menu before you come as some may feel it's limited. What they have is awesome though. Even the chicken fingers. Such a great place.

A casual Long Island classic serving all kinds of seafood as well as beer/wine options located beautifully right on the water. I was disappointed they didn 't have several menu items available during my visit in June, including soft shell crab. The menu items were hit and miss: calamari was overcooked and underseasoned, but the fish and chips and popcorn shrimp were excellent. The location has a wrap around porch that traverses behind the window where you order food, so if you 're not sitting directly in front of the window visible to the staff, you may be forgotten about for a while until your server does a full walkthrough--at least, that was my personal experience. Would like to see the location be a full walk-up window/self-service only with buzzers when your food is ready rather than trying to straddle between casual and typical dine-in. Bottom line: good seafood, definitely recommend!

I will never go back there. I regret spending money at this location. I can’t understand why our food had no taste. The food was not fresh, and It’s mind-blowing… I went to crabby Amy for take out, on my way home the food had no aroma. After eating the food, I got the worst case of a stomach flu. Fever, sweating, diarrhea and lost of appetite. I think I could’ve made better food with my air fryer.

Got the stomach flu after eating here. Lobster was not cleaned well. Fish was undercooked and the sauce that came with the fish tasted as if it was spoiled. Food was tasteless overall.

This spot is going to be one I frequent often. I ordered the oysters and fish and chips, and by far, it was some of the best, if not THE best seafood I have had in a long, long time. The fish was crispy, hot, tender, and fresh. It was so flavorful and melted in your mouth. I have never enjoyed seafood as much as I have than when I came here. And the oysters were just phenomenal. They were so fresh, they tasted like they were pulled out of the ocean minutes before they were served to us. The service was amazing, the servers were very attentive and friendly to us. I am looking forward to coming here again, hopefully for a long time.