The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Omg! We are Florida residents passing through the area and wanted to try real Staten Island pizza. Everyone told us the same thing. Go to Goodfella's! We arrived before the dinner rush and were glad we did. We were literally welcomed by everyone when we walked in. We love sitting at the bar when we travel so that we can get to know people in the area. Dana the bar tender also the manager) made me one of the best margaritas I have ever had while we waited for our pizza to arrive. We were surprised how quickly it came out but it was piping hot and OMG amazing. We had a large pie with fresh mozzarella and sausage. The red sauce on it was lite and not too sweet and the crust was crispy. I would say the pizza at Goodfella's in Staten Island definitely lives up to the hype about NY pizza. We will be back on our next trip north!

Loved the pizza. The cucumber cooler was perfect for a nice cool or hot day. It went perfectly with our pizza. The crust was on point, it was nice and crispy.

Really nice food, especially the pizza!!! Amazing service from the managers Scott, and our waiter Angelina was so nice and welcoming. Would come back

This was our first time at this location! Our Seever was George and he was FANTASTIC- personable and just made the experience even better! The food was absolutely delicious and freshly made! We will be back again and again!

One of the best restaurants with delicious food and the best valet company (Premier Valet). Dana’s espresso martinis are top tier