Stuff-a-bagel - West Islip

The new management is wonderful! it's very clean. very friendly staff. Bagels are always good! No complaining.

Place has gone downhill and prices are really getting ridiculous. I bought a bagel and it almost broke my tooth the bagel was so freaking hard. You definitely lost another customer. GOOD LUCK ? ? ?

So. My husband and I used to go to this bagel place in Udall Rd, we were always having some kind of problem with our order, then we decided to go to stuff a bagel and wow! The bagels are amazing, crunchy outside and soft inside, and the egg sandwiches are the best. Not to mention they’re costumer service is warm and kind. So we are definitely not going back to the other place.

So. My husband and I used to go to this bagel place in Udall Rd, we were always having some kind of problem with our order, then we decided to go to stuff a bagel and wow! The bagels are amazing, crunchy outside and soft inside, and the egg sandwiches are the best. Not to mention they’re costumer service is warm and kind. So we are definitely not going back to the other place.

Great spot for bagels and really good cream cheese. Not the spot if you’re looking for a specialty coffee but they’ve got all the staples. We grabbed a bit of lox too and that was excellent.