West New York Pizza - West NY

Unfortunate experience. Ordered two extra large pies and received a pretty mangled pie. Pies were barely warm too. The owner proceeded to get hostile and blamed my doorman for the mess. He reasoned that because only one pie was mangled, it could not have possibly been his delivery guy. Food drop off area in our lobby has cameras to prove otherwise.This was more than a cosmetic issue as some slices were missing ingredients because of the shift.Pizza is average to slightly above average and too salty for my taste. Too many good places around here to go through this type of experience: Urban Tomato, la sorrentina, Rasco's are some great places that come to mind.

Easily the best pizza in WNY. Garlic Knots are phenomenal.

Just stopped for a quick slice. Wasn't good or bad just ok. REPLY TO OWNER:It was the flavor of the particular slice. Maybe it was sitting out all day or maybe just didn't have flavor. I'm sure your other food is better but I can't speak to that. I feel a 3 out of 5 was more fair.

I’ve been ordering from this place consistently for the last 2 years and have never had a bad meal. All of their pasta and pizza pies, especially the penne alle vodka pizza and cheesesteak pizza, are fantastic. You could put a blind fold on and pick a random item on the menu and it’d be good. Thanks for putting out such a consistently good meal, WNYP!

This place really is the best pizza spot in town. We live right next to the place on park and walk three blocks past that place to get wny pizza. The owner is always there and a really decent dude. The pizza dough is really well made and crispy. Sauce not overly sweet and what makes Jersey pizza good. Cheese is the good kind, not rubbery or greasy. Toppings are plenty and they have some crazy special pies. Called in late towards close and the stayed open late AND made a custom requested pie. They also have table games which always make it fun for my wife and I to get some slices there and have a cheap date.