Scarpetta Beach - MONTAUK

Food was very good. Wine lists price point did not include much of anything below $125/bottle and most was $250+ but it’s the Hamptons so I get it. Wine by glass was fine. Food was really good, we had the burata app and the ravioli cacio e Pepe and the scallops entree. Both were plenty of food, so serving size was enough. Initially the music reminded of being back at Ibiza but eventually they went to a more appropriate playlist. We sat outside. Very nice property and the ambiance was very nice. Had an after dinner drink at the bar which, too is quite nice. It’s not inexpensive. Dinner was $230 all in for two people.

Our favorite Hamptons restaurant. Never fails to impress.

Food was equivalent of eating at a mediocre diner. Soggy pasta and soggy Halibut. Could even make an espresso martini with fresh espresso. The espresso based drink was made in bulk the day before make it flat and rancid. Great view- it’s the ocean but it ends with that.

Spent a few days here in Montauk and while we didn’t stay at Gurneys we very much enjoyed the restaurant, service and the food was excellent

We had a good time. We had a reservation and had options presented to us which we appreciated. We chose outside and grabbed a couple drinks at the bar until table was ready. Bartender was very accommodating. The server was good. The food was good. I would recommend and come back again. Thank you.