Osprey Bar Lounge - Avis

Possibly the best Italian on the Island. Not inexpensive but the food is very good.

We sat in the bar area and had great service from the bartender. Beautiful quaint inn and restaurant, excellent food. The only detraction was the loud group of...

Excellent food and wonderful server!! Everybody around us seemed to be very pleased as well.

Loved everything about Caci from the bocce courts out front to the cozy bar with a knowledgeable bartender who makes a killer espresso martini with real espress...

Overall a great dining experience. Food was excellent... split the gnocchi dish as an appetizer which was outstanding, had the osso buco and the lamb chops both...

The ambiance was pleasant and the service was good, but the prices were high. Dining on Islands always tends to be expensive.

The steak for two was outstanding, as was the tuna tartare. The only issue was that the restaurant could have used more than 2 servers, even though it wasn't ve...

We ordered the eggs Benedict which was fabulous!! The others ordered the scrambled eggs, more like a frittata. The waiter told the chef and brought back a plate...

Great wine list and food was delicious. We sat at a table but bar is also lovely and an option for the full menu. Will go again next time we’re on Shelter Islan...

Had a great experience for a Sunday night meal. Seemed like it was an off-peak time as the place was not full, so that may have worked to our advantage. It was...